[Dec/2022-Archive-March/2022 | Marketing] Wanting – Power of Mimetic Desire

Intro – Social Gravity

  • Rely on others to see what’s worth wanting
  • After basic needs – go to desires
    • Mimesis – Learn desire externally from “models”
    • Humans fight not because of different but because of sameness – enemy twins
  • Religious sacrifice
  • Company where people measure on perf objectives instead of relative performance – minimize mimetic rivalry
  • Model of desire – everyone’s a potential model with Facebook
    • FB models are “inside our world”

Chap1 Hidden Models – Romantic Lies, Infant Truth

  • We learn our desire from models
  • Torches of freedom – Edward Bernays
    • Female smoking a taboo at the time, Frame women smoking as a way for women to challenge male power “torches of freedom”
    • Hire women to smoke conspicuously
    • Give illusion of autonomy, models are powerful when hidden, if want someone passionate about something, want them to believe the desire is their own
  • Romance:
    • Backoff in relationship when women push too hard
    • The more the women deny, the more Girard wants the women – other man needs this women – “modeling the desirability of women”
    • Guy wants his girlfriend back when the women posted on insta with a new boyfriend who’s “high status”
  • Advertising Irony
    • When being sold something too hard – not good
    • Illusion of Choice
  • Financial Market – herding of investors

Chap2 Distorted Reality – Freshmen

  • Steve Jobs and computer buyer Friedland – quirky behavior
    • Later becomes reality distortion field <- author says its because Steve Jobs “want” differently
  • “Imitate – but not too much” behavior
  • People who’re far away from us (celebristan) vs. those who are close (Freshmanistan)
    • Celebristan – different universe, different “wants” 
    • Rivalry from Proximity
    • Freshmanistan – close in contact and unspoken rivalry
  • Celebristan – external mediator of desire (outside our world)
    • Time/Space/Social Status between celebristan vs. Imitators
    • Imitated openly & freely
    • Add distance by Secrecy (i.e. Satoshi Nakamoto in Celebristan)
    • Hierarchy in company faciliate Celebristan (i.e. CEO vs. entry-level employee)
  • Freshmanistan – internal mediator of desire (inside our world)
    • High Rivalry
    • High school freshman – unspoken battle of differentiation
    • “I want what you want”
  • Distortion of Reality
    • Distortion 1 : Misappropriation of Wonder
      • Openly applaud wonders for models in Celebristan, secretly applaud wonders for models in Freshmanistan (because of rivalry)
    • Distortion 2 : Cult of Experts
      • Example: Tim Ferris’s Five Bullet Friday: experts tell you what you should want
      • “Guru” – deconstruct layer’s behind someone’s authority
    • Distortion 3: Reflexivity
      • Self-fulfilling : our perception of reality changes reality
      • Example: people’s willingness to speak freely depends on their unconscious perception of how popular their opinions are
      • Example: Elizabeth Holmes – Walgreen contract brings more action
  • Social Mediation – social media & mimetic desire

Chap3 Social Contagion – cycles of desire

  • Mimetic Desire spreads like energy
  • Lamborghini vs. Ferrari 
    • Innovation from imitation 
    • Mimetic Rivalry, where one person is Matador the other the bull
  • Memes
  • Flywheel effect
    • Cycle-1: Negative cycle, rivalry
    • Cycle-2: Positive cycle, mutual good, mindset of abundance; 
    • Example of business flywheel: great product -> elite athelete -> amateur -> public
  • Zappos Negative Flywheel example:
    • Downtown proj
    • Community that has lost the difference (no model vs. imitator) – will have worse mimetic rivalry (freshmanistan type)
      • Tony want to create “college env” to accelerate Serendipity but seems he got freshmanistan
    • Non-hierarchical Company
  • Mimetic Rivalry (pair-wise) vs. Mimetic Crisis (Zappos example)
  • Have a clear hierarchy of values – antidote to mimetic conformity

Chap4 The Invention of Blame

  • Scapegoat mechanism
  • Celebristan vs. Freshmanstan – in mimetic contagion
    • Ppl in pool analogy
    • Mob/Crowd Psychology
  • Scapegoat mechanism also “kill tyrants” 
  • Scapegoat – demigod ability before death – unifying & healing the community
  • Online Study (Weibo) – anger spreads faster than other emotion, because anger spreads across weak ties between people
  • Sacrificial Thinking
    • I.e. Jesus

Chap5 Anti-Mimetic

  • Goal & Systems
  • Mimetic Systems
    • More Mimetic Force, more people want to use it
    • Systems of Desires
  • Example: Restaurant / Michelin Star
    • Michelin Guide – mediator of desire
    • Mimetic Marketing
    • Also sell tools & Services to restaurants (if they don’t agree, then …)

Chap6 Disruptive Empathy – break through thin desires

  • Disruptive Empathy
    • Detail Negative Mimesis
    • Know People at their Core: Stories of deeply fulfilling action
  • Sympathy vs. Empathy
    • Sympathy: feeling together, empathy: feeling inside
    • Sympathy can be hijacked by mimesis
  • Thick Desires
    • Against mimetic desire
    • i.e. desire to retire is thin vs. desire to invest more time with family is thick
    • Envy: Engine of destructive mimetic desire
    • Thin desire fluctuate up & down
    • Thick desire always goes up
  • Deeply fulfilling experiences
    • Identify core motivational drive
    • Fulfillment story: action -> meaning to the person
    • Kick off positive memisis
    • Fulfillment story as window 

Chap7 Transcendent leadership – great leader inspire & shape desire

  • Mimetic Desire & Leadership
    • Immanent vs. Transcendent Desire
      • Inside vs. Outside the System
      • Transcendent desire is extending space & time, via vision 
      • 增量 vs. 存量
  • Five skills of transcendent leadership
    • 1. Shift Gravity – cultivate desire in students and let them stufy
    • 2. Speed of truth – important for org
      • Pursuit of truth is anti-mimetic
    • 3. Discern desire
    • 4. Sit quietly in a room – silent retreat
    • 5. Filter feedback
      • Lean Startup Methodology is immanent desire (based on data feedback), which is “follow instead of lead”
      • Elon Musk’s “reckless” opinion of market data

Chap8 Mimetic Future

  • Facebook marks world’s entry into Freshmanistan
  • Big Tech
    • Google – deity
    • Facebook – love & belonging
    • Amazon – Security
    • Apple – Sex/Status
  • Two dimension
    • Celebristan vs. Freshmanistan
    • Mimetic vs. Anti-mimetic
  • Instruments vs. Relationships
    • Engineering desire vs. transformation of desire
    • Engineering desire
      • Tech comp stand as mediator of desire between ppl & things
      • Centrally planned wanting
    • Transformation of desire
      • Calculating vs. Meditating thought
      • Meditative thought as anti-dote to mimesis
  • Pivotal space: family / imagination / work
  • Three social inventions: Scapegoat / Marketing Economy / the third one forming

Leave a Reply